Paid Link Crackdown

Julie — Tue, 17 Apr 2007 16:01:07 +0000

It’s all over the place: Google is looking at ways to get bitchy about paid links and hidden links.

I hate hidden links, simply because playing games with CSS to hide links from users is a clear sign of some form of dumbassery occurring.

But paid links are a really messy area. There’s a billion comments in a billion forums right now pro-killing paid links, con killing paid links, etc. An argument is being made that when you buy directory links, such as Yahoo! Directory, you’re not paying for the link, but for having the link reviewed.

That strikes me as complete poo. You mean to tell me that it really costs Yahoo! $299 to ‘review’ my submission? Man, their reviewers must be pulling amazing hourly rate. I want to be a reviewer. I could sit at home with the cats and wear sweatpants all the time. I could bike all day and review all night while drinking beer and watching the Fox Reality Channel on cable.

The only way the $299 makes sense is if Yahoo! is in fact charging on the basis of the value of the link. Which, as we’re all aware, is the truth of the matter, or else none of us would ever pay the going rate.

Other types of paid links are similarly sticky. Text link brokerage is sort of sleazy — it’s rare that I see an example where brokered text links don’t look spammy on a site. But what of a paid review? Sure, most reviewers won’t give quality reviews just for the freebie or the cash, but everyone lies if they claim the gift or the $$ doesn’t make an impact. It’s a truism of public relations that schmoozing works.

I just feel like, of all the dodgy techniques to go after, paid links are both hard to justify the various nuances, and likely difficult to build into an algorithm. How about devaluing Squidoo and MySpace linking? That would be super-easy, and probably have more immediate merit.

Edit: One of the my favorite summaries to date: The Real Reason Google Doesn’t Like Paid Links. It suits my sense of tinfoil-hattery.

Spring Break: Comment Spam Gone Wild!

Julie — Thu, 15 Mar 2007 00:15:03 +0000

In honor of Spring Break, we remind you why spam filters and comment moderation are blogger tools to cherish:

Hello !
payday http://payday-loans-07.blogspot.com
buycialis http://buy-cialisss.blogspot.com
cheaptramado http://cheaptramadol3.blogspot.com
airline http://airlinetickets3.blogspot.com
cialis http://buycialis-px7.blogspot.com
tramadol http://buytramadol07.blogspot.com
creditcardonline http://credit3card3online3.blogspot.com
autoinsuranceonline http://auto3insurance1online3.blogspot.com
loans http://payday209loans.blogspot.com
I believe you will have a lot of exciting times ahead in your future with the web!
airline tickets http://airlinetickets379.blogspot.com
valium http://valium-btr80.blogspot.com
adipex http://adipex-pex.blogspot.com
fast cash http://fast-cash-good.blogspot.com
credit loans http://credit-loans2007.blogspot.com
cash advance loan http://cash1advance1loan.blogspot.com
cash advance http://cash-advance2007.blogspot.com
tramadol http://tramadol3akak3.blogspot.com
viagra http://viagra-0ak0.blogspot.com
phentermine http://phentermine-minus-kg.blogspot.com
tramadol http://tramadol-1usa.blogspot.com
I believe you will have a lot of exciting times ahead in your future with the web!
carinsuranceonline http://car-insurance-online07.blogspot.com
freecreditreport http://freecreditreport07.blogspot.com
viagra http://viagra-bomba.blogspot.com
cialis http://cialis-d5d.blogspot.com
viagra http://viagra-akkk.blogspot.com
xanax http://xanax-akx5.blogspot.com
phentermine http://phentermine45akl7.blogspot.com
cialis http://cialis-3ak7d.blogspot.com
health insurance http://health1insurance1online1.blogspot.com
All the best!

All the best indeed. What baffles me about this approach is that as someone who has done e-mail marketing, if you’re at all smart you figure out what triggers spam filters. Given that there are some pretty predictable comment-spam standards for the big blogging softwares — and that comment moderation tends to be default to on rather than off for neophyte users — you’d think some of these clowns would actually, you know, try to link-spam one at a time. (Most of the set-defaults tend to trigger at two. I’d feel bad for pointing this out, but it is that obvious if you look in either WordPress or Blogger settings.)

This is why the Big Three created the nofollow standard to start with. I tend not to believe that even on some of the bigger sites (read: popular and ranking) that even slipping in one or two links at a time, though methodically, does all that much for overall performance of the site.

It’s far better to piss people off and create link-bait, in my mind. It’s also more fun!

Between Stations » comment spam

Paid Link Crackdown

Spring Break: Comment Spam Gone Wild!